FINAL Update 21 November 2021
This page will be used to collect requirements and rate alternative operating systems for an Acer Aspire One Netbook (532h). Originally setup to evaluate alternatives to win7 home but turned into somewhat of a hobby. The evaluation checklist is tailored to my world, but may be useful to others. Slow/Low Priority project ... Thoughts/comments welcome.
Summary (notes/observations below the test tables)
Jan 2021: Playing w/ SSD in AAO. Win10 reinstall on an SSD - Notes
-----
2021 Status: AAO is STILL alive 10+ years!
Now used as our one and only Windows machine. Also periodically used as a home Network Monitor, via USB boot to Network Security Toolkit ( NST 32) - Notes
2021 Plans: - Attempt to breath final life into AAO - Win 10 has bogged down a lot!
- Dual Boot to favorite Linux
- OS Testing will continue, but likely to slow
----- Latest Tests
Ratings: A=Perfect (out of box), B=Little Tweak,
C=Big Tweak, D=Works/Flaky, F=Total Fail
|
|
| | |
Fix Major Win7 Annoyances |
|
| | |
Fast user switching |
|
| | |
Personalization1
|
|
| | |
Autorun Portable Devices
|
|
| | |
Upgrade $$$!
|
Free! |
| | |
General Simplicity3 |
|
| | |
Our World
|
|
| | |
Home Network Participant |
|
| | |
Music Library Participant
|
|
| | |
Home Applications |
|
| | |
Software |
|
| | |
Apps/Add-ons Availability |
|
| | |
Ongoing Evolution/Support |
|
| | |
Hardware (532h-2588)
|
|
| | |
Touch pad (2-finger scroll)
|
|
| | |
Webcam |
|
| | |
Card Reader
|
|
| | |
Speakers/Audio |
|
| | |
Audio Input (mic) |
|
| | |
Audio Output |
|
| | |
External Monitor
|
|
| | |
WiFi |
|
| | |
Ethernet |
|
| | |
Power Management
|
|
| | |
Keyboard/Function Keys
|
|
| | |
USB Slots |
|
| | |
Misc |
|
| | |
Desktop/Window Manager |
|
| | |
Version Tested |
|
| | |
1 Change Wallpaper, Screensaver, Visual Style, etc - Where Win 7 Starter totally fails
2 VERY Clumsy with wifi, mapped drives, network printers, and non-windows peers
3 Intuitiveness, e.g. Finding/installing drivers/software, locating files, Security & Maintenance reboots ......
N See Notes
Latest Test Notes
SSD + Win 10 Reinstall
-
Overall: In process, Attempt #3! Attempting fresh Win10 install on SSD to breath some life into AAO.
- Motivation: AAO Hard disk has now turned 11!
- Had an unused Samsung EVO 850 (250g) SSD* on my workbench ...
- Still have a couple of Windows-Only Apps in the house, AAO now is our only windoze machine!
- Current AAO Win 10 has never been snappy, but has slowed after years of updates.
- Notes:
- Attempted to create System Image Backup of AAO's original disk. It ran & ran & ran, then ... Failed
Decided to leave old disk in tact and install anew ... probably a lot of win junk on the old instance anyhoo
- Acer said: Windows 10: Reinstall Windows 10 after the free upgrade
Sooo ... Visited the Microsoft media creation tool using the browser on AAO. - Attempt #1: Downloaded and installed Win 10 Home - very slow and too much junk
- Attempt #2: Installed Win 10 Home N - Looked to be lighter ... BUT ...
AAO Digital License didn't work! It won't activate. Back to Win 10 Home. - Attempt #3: Back to Win 10 Home ... it was on the same USB image - no need to re-download.
- Attempt #3 Notes - April 2021: Side tracked, picking up where I left this off
- Still pretty sluggish. Not sure this is worth the trouble. Some tweaking/testing before I yank it
December 2020
- Manjaro KDE Plasma - Live Boot from SSD: Wow! Nice & fast! Same version installed to SSD - BAD! Notes
June 2020
May 2020
- Elive - Works great on AAO, would take a lot of getting used to! Notes
- Bodhi - Minimal w/ Enlightenment - Nice! Notes
Feb 2020
2020: Our AAO is STILL alive and kicking, 9 years old and counting!
Our Aspire's role is typically a Network Monitor on IoT subnet, running Network Security Toolkit ( NST 28) - Notes
Other tests Planned for 2020
- Lightweight OS alternatives - see how long AAO keeps kicking!
- Other Network Security tools
2020 Tests
Ratings: A=Perfect (out of box), B=Little Tweak,
C=Big Tweak, D=Works/Flaky, F=Total Fail
|
|
Bodhi 5.1
Runs Pretty Well!
Notes |
Elive 3.0.6
Pretty fast
Very Different
Notes |
NST 32
In
Process
Notes |
Manjaro
KDE Plasma
GREAT!
Notes
|
Fix Major Win7 Annoyances |
|
|
|
|
|
Fast user switching |
F |
F |
F |
B |
F
|
Personalization1
|
B |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Autorun Portable Devices
|
A |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Upgrade $$$!
|
Free! |
Free/Donate! |
Free/Donate |
Free & Pro |
Free/Donate
|
General Simplicity3 |
B |
B |
CN |
B |
A+
|
Our World
|
|
|
|
|
|
Home Network Participant |
A |
A |
C |
B |
B
|
Music Library Participant
|
B |
B |
B |
A |
B
|
Home Applications |
B |
A |
B |
n/a |
A
|
Software |
|
|
|
|
|
Apps/Add-ons Availability |
B |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Ongoing Evolution/Support |
TBD |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Hardware (532h-2588)
|
|
|
|
|
|
Touch pad (2-finger scroll)
|
BN |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Webcam |
A |
A |
A |
|
A
|
Card Reader
|
A |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Speakers/Audio |
|
A |
A |
A |
A |
Audio Input (mic) |
|
|
A |
|
|
Audio Output |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
External Monitor
|
CN |
D |
B |
D |
B
|
WiFi |
A |
A |
A |
B |
B
|
Ethernet |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Power Management
|
BN |
A |
B |
A |
A
|
Keyboard/Function Keys
|
D |
B |
A |
C |
B
|
USB Slots |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A
|
Misc |
|
|
|
|
|
Desktop/Window Manager |
Pixel |
Moksha
based on Enlightenment |
Enlightenment (17.6)
Customized |
Mate |
KDE Plasma
|
Version Tested |
Version:
February 2020
Release date:2020-02-12
Kernel version:4.19
Size:2985 MB |
5.1.0 64bit
March 2020
Based on Ubuntu 18.04 (Bionic Beaver) |
Elive Stable 3.06
Based on Debian "wheezy" |
NST 32 SVN:11992 |
20.1.2-201019 KDE 5.19.5 Kernal 5.8.16-2 64-bit
|
1 Change Wallpaper, Screensaver, Visual Style, etc - Where Win 7 Starter totally fails
2 VERY Clumsy with wifi, mapped drives, network printers, and non-windows peers
3 Intuitiveness, e.g. Finding/installing drivers/software, locating files, Security & Maintenance reboots ......
N See Notes
2020 Test Notes
Manjaro KDE Plasma
- Overall: Still Investigating. Worked VERY well when I booted from USB - Live boot.
Same version installed to SSD from VERY same USB, is running like crap... what the heck is going on here!
- Motivation: Have settled on Majaro KDE for my Raspberry Pi desktop replacement project - it has been working very well. Decided to boot it up on a couple of older X86 machines to see how it does, including AAO!
- Official info @ https://manjaro.org/download/#kde-plasma.
- Notes:
- Start here @ https://manjaro.org/support/firststeps/
- Downloaded manjaro-kde-20.1.2-201019-linux58.iso (2.9g) and burned it to 8g USB stick using Etcher
(on a Raspberry Pi 4 Manjaro Desktop!)
- Booted right up - pretty snappy
- Live Boot Tests
- AAO Hardware
- WiFi - worked fine.
One little glitch, it didnt dicsonnect when I plugged Ethernet. Probably by design
- Webcam via VLC, seemed to work fine. smooth movement!
- Audio - tested using YouTube video via Firefox, smooth, 40% CPU max!
- Internal Speakers worked fine
- Headphone jack, switched when plugged, worked fine
- External Monitor - worked! Popup when plugged, options of mirror, dual left/right, etc
- Some flaky behavior when using dual monitors, mouse stuck on Monitor#2.
I didn't fiddle with it,
- Function Keys - Most work fine, WiFi was exception, had to enable/disable via panel
- Software - I like Manjaro A LOT!
- Active Project
- Official Repository is quite full and active
- Also access to Arch AUR applications, VERY nice, integrated into Software GUI
NST 32
- Overall: In Process. Looks really good, so far! Seems much faster than current (NST 28)
- Motivation: Our AAO runs NST most of the time, monitors our IoT/Things subnet. Accessed via browser
- Have been running NST 28 for quite a while, thought I'd try 32.
- Also sort of a test of Fedora 32, NST underpinnings
- Official info @ https://www.networksecuritytoolkit.org/nst/index.html
- Notes:
- Too big for usual NST 8g Memory stick - first time! Used 16g for live boot test
Downloaded nst-30-11992.x86_64.iso from https://sourceforge.net/projects/nst/
- Live Boot test
- GUI seems MUCH faster - may be Fedora 32
- Does support multiple users, not sure I'd say FAST user switching
- Home Network, SHOULD Work. Samba installed, may have to play with smb.conf. I suspect it is secure. I may have to set min protocol and WG name in our world
- AAO Hardware most seems to work ...
- skipped a few, but suspect cam, mic and such will work
- Some FCN keys work, be careful with external monitor
- Something went bump switching to external monitor, freeze! Had to reboot, didn't dig into it.
- Some Mate config screens didn't fit on AAO display using default resolution ... probably can be fixed, easy to work-around
- Looks good enough to push on ...
- Install to faster/larger Thumb Drive (instead of messing with fedora persistence)
Takes quite a while. Watch Anaconda installer, I always mess it up. BE PATIENT!
- Run Set NST System Passwords - sets passwords *and* starts web worlkd (NSTWUI)
- Post install - pretty random setup and testing, mostly for my world. Getting old, need to leave tracks
- <More to come>
Elive
- Overall: Runs well on AAO, but too different to operate. Probably OK if this were only OS in use
- Motivation: Just HAD to try ...
- Very intrigued by Enlightenment Desktop *and* support for older/slower hardware
- Taglines on main web page are sooo good ...
"... Elive, maybe the best Linux OS ever made
- And probably the only distro you'll stay with -
But Elive is not for everyone, are you the exception?"
"...Do not waste your time doing your own customizations which already took 14 years of polished work here."
- Official info @ https://www.elivecd.org/
- Notes
- Download immediately with donation or wait an hour of so. Interesting technique, reasonable!
- Started with Stable version 3.0.6. Live USB image w/ persistence!
- Install notes - first time boot
- Persistence is option right out the gates!
- Skipped hardware accelerated desktop (OpenGL), don't think OpenGL supports AAO GP
- Post boot setup is nice/thorough!
- Very keyboard/hot-key oriented. Would take some getting used to
- alt+esc: Launcher
- Hotkeys help in toolbar helps! (looks like boat throw ring)
- easiest to left-click on desktop to bring up app menu
- Boots sloowly AND presents GUI WHILE things are still ramping up, confusing
- AAO Hardware - so far so good
- Cam - tested via Cheese ... fired it up via Terminal
- Power management is here someplace, would take some GUI tweaking
- AAO hardware seemed to work well in general
- Software - I did a lot of fiddling via Terminal. I suspect all will work, but may take some effort
- Windows network wasn't browsable, couple of smb.conf tweaks didn't help
- Launcher wasn't much use - comes up, but doesn't fire stuff up - trackpad?
- Quite a lot pre-installed software! 3 or 4 internet browsers, for example
- Repository seemed pretty well populated - elivedc.org
Bodhi
- Overall: Runs pretty well, nice and light. Will probably take some tweaking for full time use
- Motivation: Have noticed a couple of lightweight with Enlightenment desktop ... interesting
- Official info @ https://www.bodhilinux.com/w/wiki/.
- Notes:
- Downloaded and etchered a 16g usb drive using bodhi-5.1.0-64.iso - 820M Download
- Live booted, didn't install. No obvious way to add persistence
- Nice/light install not a lot of extra apps
- AAO Hardware seems to work fine
- Settings are a little different - felt light/minimal. Suspect brute force to adjust some things
- Did not get image on ext (vga) monitor, didn't fiddle much. Should work 'Presentation Mode"
- Browser didn't seem to handle html5(?) - youtube visit failed. VERY odd
- Little sluggish at times, but may have been the old/slow USB stick I used
- Interesting App Center @ http://www.bodhilinux.com/a/.
- Pretty nice library, AppStore-Like installs
- Traditional Package MGR also included
Debian/RaspberryPI
- Overall: Quite painless. Seems a little sluggish at times, but it works, usable - especially for Pi/Pixel fans!
- Motivation: I have a lot of PI's, just wanted to see how this works on AAO
- Official info @ https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/pixel-pc-mac/
- Notes
- ISO Download was 3.1g. from https://downloads.raspberrypi.org/rpd_x86_latest
- Created Bootable (16g) usb using Etcher from https://www.balena.io/
- Booted RIGHT UP!
- Even had option to run with Persistence
- Automagically Fired up "Welcome to Raspberry Pi" dialog to take of must-do's
- Language/Keyboard
- Change Password
- Set up WiFi
- Update OS and software friends
- Restart!
- AAO Hardware looks pretty good!
- WiFi worked right out of the blocks
- Webcam, OK
- Touchpad worked fine, even 2-finger scrolling. No fine tuning w/o installing help, tho
- Audio seems fine, external jacks too! I didn't test Mic jack
- Keyboard/Function Keys were flaky, some may work
- External (vga) Monitor works ... but ...
- Function Key does not seem to switch
- Dual Monitors (Appearance Settings in Pixel) seemed to always mirror the display
- Power Management: Monitored AAO battery, no pre-installed power management utils
- Other Observations/Experiences
- One inexplicable lockup - happened when switching from Ethernet back to WiFi
- Seemed a tad sluggish at times - cpu pegged when visiting youtube, for example.
2018/2019 Activities
- December 2018
- November 2018
- Manjaro - It was OK, lots of stuff on there! "User Friendly" - Notes
- October 2018
- August 2018
- Network Security Toolkit NST 28 - In process w/ some struggles - Notes
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
2018/2019 Tests
Ratings: A=Perfect (out of box), B=Little Tweak,
C=Big Tweak, D=Works/Flaky, F=Total Fail |
|
Ubuntu
Studio |
(Stretch)
|
LinuxLite |
(Fedora)
|
NeverWare CloudReady |
Manjaro |
Fix Major Annoyances |
Aborted
Notes |
Works
|
Nah
Notes |
GREAT
Notes |
Nice!
Notes |
Works
|
|
Fast user switching |
|
A |
|
B |
|
CN |
|
Personalization1
|
B |
A |
A |
A |
C |
C |
|
Autorun Portable Devices
|
A |
A |
D |
A |
A |
A |
D |
Upgrade $$$!
|
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 (home) |
$0 |
General Simplicity3 |
B |
A |
B |
B |
B |
A |
B |
Our World
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Home Network Participant |
A |
A |
DN |
A |
A |
CN |
A |
Music Library Participant
|
BN |
A |
no test |
C |
B |
D |
B |
Home Applications |
n/a |
A |
|
A |
n/a |
C |
A |
Software |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Apps/Add-ons Availability |
A |
A |
D |
A |
A |
C |
BN |
Ongoing Evolution/Support |
B |
A |
B |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Hardware (532h-2588)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Touch pad (2-finger scroll)
|
A |
A |
B |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Webcam |
-- |
F |
DN |
A |
|
A |
A |
Card Reader
|
|
F |
DN |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Audio Input (mic) |
-- |
no test |
C |
A |
B |
|
no test |
Audio Output |
A |
A |
C |
A |
A |
A |
A |
External Monitor
|
|
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
B |
WiFi |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Ethernet |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Power Management
|
A |
AN |
B |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Keyboard/Function Keys
|
A |
B |
B |
C |
A |
Some |
Some |
USB Slots |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
B |
Misc |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Window Manager |
Gnome |
Xfce |
Xfce |
Xfce |
Mate |
(me thinks)
|
Xfce |
Version Tested |
26 SVN 9267
(64-bit) |
Xenial Xerus 16.04.3 LTS
(64-bit) |
9.3.0 amd64 (Live ISO) |
3.6
(32-bit) |
28 SVN 10439
(64-bit) |
(64-bit)
|
17.1.12
(64-bit) |
N See Notes
2018/2019 Test Notes
NST 28
- Overall: It works, I'm using it, but I STILL don't like NTOPng!
Still poking around, but Network Security Tookkit NST 28 runs quite well on AAO.
Some new/different tools, but I'll get used to it
- Motivation: My AAO runs NST most of the time, it watches over our 'Things' subnet (IoT monitor), but also periodically used to debug/monitor network. AAO has been running NST 24 for a few years ... struggled with upgrades in the past
- Notes (used Getting_Started guide to get things rolling)
- ISO Download was 3.6g - nst-28-10439.x86_64.iso, may be too new for me (8/24/2018)
- Created bootable 4g USB using Mint's Disk utility (Restore Disk Image) booted up fine
- Initial AAO tests using live boot
- AAO Keyboard seemed fine. fcn keys all seemed to do what they are supposed to
- External Monitor worked right out of the box
- Power Management seemed fine too - battery monitoring, etc
- Sound/Audio - Seemed to be more utilities in this release (Players, Mixer controls, etc)
- Output sound seemed to work fine out of the box
- Did not see Mic detected, but I'll bet it would work if needed
- Install to 32g USB drive for more testing ...
- I don't use persistent USB boot with NST, can't recall why. "Install to Hardisk" w/ big/fast usb stick
- Install is slow, seems unresponsive at times but wait it out ...
- Had to delete all partitions on target USB - could not figure out how to get install to format/use
- Looks like 18g avail on 32g USB after install - plenty for now
- Ran System/Configuration/NST Package Management -> Upgrade NST System ... seemed to be worth it
- Tools I've configured/used
- NSTWUI - Webfrontend @ https:<ip address>:9943/nstwui
- Odd, I had to bookmark /etc/nst.conf - useful nst passwords in here! And yes, I did run nstpasswd!
- Struggling with resolving local hostnames ... more to come
- Network/Monitors
- Network Bandwidth Monitor works fine - eth & wifi
- NTOP came up fine @ https:<ip address>:3001
- Default uc/pw = admin/admin (DID I run nstpasswd?)
- NTOPNG Community edition only ... I'll get used to it!
- Security/Intrusion Detection
- Snort/Sguil is working! NOW I remember WHY I started this NST upgrade!
- Sguil UI is new @ https:<ip address>:7743, PW is in nst.conf! (don't get me started)
- MUCH easier than installing snort & friends!
- Lot to learn here ....
- <still working here>
- Lanalyzer/Packet Capture Tools (keep it simple - Single Tap capture/tshark decode)
- Works fine, with stumbles on capture filter syntax, of course! Just copy from examples!
- Handy link/tool - hex packet decoder @ https://hpd.gasmi.net/
- Very handy tools here - lot to learn/see, addictive/fun if you can see entire network
- Network/Tools & Utilities - Looks like there are new ones here, nice!
- Stumbled on Cockpit web console via SSH - Quite nice
- start: systemctl enable --now cockpit.socket
- Access via: http:<ip address>:9090
- Looks like AAO will be fine with NST 28 (test with snort/sguil and NTOP running)
- Processors < 50%
- Mem & Swap - around 1.5 of 2.6g
- Kismet - haven't used before, struggling thru set up ... yeeesh!
Parrot OS
- Paused - Loaded latest version of ParrotOS Security Edition on USB Drive
- Motivation: Home networking issue driving me nuts! Parrot worked great in the past
- USB Via Etcher - 32-Bit downloaded (in haste, but that's OK) - Parrot-security-4.4_i386.iso
back to original USB stick (overwriting Manjaro, in haste again!)
- Notes as I go (but not right now, I need to fix something!)
- Ack - fumbling with persistence ... paused for now
- <more to come>
Manjaro
- Overall - It worked, seemed nice. A bit overloaded/cluttered for me. Lots of preinstalled stuff!
- Nice/user-friendly Linux Dist - https://manjaro.org/
- Testing cut a bit short when I reused the USB memory stick for Parrot! I had a network issue
- USB Live test - no persistence, just a quick test
- Motivation: Actually looking for alternatives to Mint for my main desktop, had it on USB, decided to test on AAO
- Notes as I go
- Apparently based on arch linux ... Been on my list!
- Looks pretty good - sort of easy to use. LOTS of stuff preinstalled
- Package Manager is odd interface, not sure what it is. No apt or yum from commandline? Its pacman!
- External Monitor worked, but kinda wierd. I didn't mess with dual monitors - default was mirror, I think
- USB's seemed to work, but looked like it was trying to autorun flash drives (failed to mount, op pending)
- Not as simple/intuitive as I'd hoped
CloudReady
- Neverware CloudReady Home Edition - Chromium OS on a stick!
Overall - It works, Neverware did a good job - it's ChromeOS
- On my ToDo List for a long while, noticed that AAO 532h on the list of supported devices!
- Motivation: I needed a Chromebook to test out an idea - we'll see how close this comes!
- Notes as I go
- Zip download was 1g - cloudready-free-68.4.59-64-bit.zip from Home Edition Download Page
- etcher.io for bootable USB (my fav). Using 16g mem stick
- Came up fine - little sluggish, but that may be old USB
- Hardware appears to work BETTER than advertised in Aspire 532h Features & Exceptions doc
- My webcam worked out of the blocks - which was GREAT because my test involved video calls!
- May just be how chromebooks work, but adding apps can be fun(ny)!
Using Web Store, some get added as 'apps' on OS others may be extensions in chrome browser.
Be careful in Web Store, seemed like a lot of junk to weed thru
- My Checklist
- Looks like it will support multiple user accounts - sort-of Fast-User Switching
- Home network participation w/ some help
- Installed Network File Share for Chrome OS (in spite of 2 our of 5 star rating)
- Printing - network printers didn't work out of the box, installed cloudprint app, but not what I was expecting.
- AAO Hardware - card reader, external monitor, output audio and such seemed fine
- Some minor slowdowns/sluggishness, but overall quite usable
- Enough of this - it works, it's OK, It's ChromeOS
Linux Lite
- Overall, VERY NICE! Runs great, almost everything worked w/o tweaks - one little bump
- Forgot about Linux Lite! Have been using on slow PCs for some time ... Should be great on AAO
- Took a few tries, but ...
- Got it running on persistent USB (4g stick with 2g persistence) using UNetbootin
- Really struggled to get it connected to wifi initially - ended up being the keyboard! Drove me nuts!
- Other notes
- Tested all multimedia with VLC - will need to install music player
Debian
- Overall: Nah, looked like most stuff would work - messed around with USB boot too long - aborted
- Messing with Debian Stretch for another project, could have sworn I ran on AAO before, but no record of it!
- Have had good luck/performance with Xfce on AAO, will start there
- Struggling to create bootable USB with persistence ... stretch may have changed things? Some guides:
- Test notes
- Never did get USB w/ persistence working ... messed around long enough
- Failed to browse home network via file manager - I didn't dig into this
- Failed to find a couple of my favorite packages in repository
- Attempted quick test of webcam using VLC media player - failed, but I didn't attempt to tweak/fix
- Audio output worked out of box but no obvious volume control on desktop - used alsamixer
- Audio in (Mic) appeared to be working - didn't find recorder, but managed to get some feedback going
- Did not get card-reader working - simply quick test, didn't look into this either
Ubuntu Studio
- Overall: Booted for the fun of it, but it ran remarkably well! Didn't spend a lot of time on AAO, but did install on a bigger machine to do some video editing work
- Xenial Xerus 16.04.3 LTS (64-bit), actually quite snappy on 2g AAO
- Power Management seemed to work right out of box ... BUT ...
- one odd event where battery level went from 40% to critical/alert/plugin-now! May be AAO battery
- Most AAO Hardware worked fine - I didn't attempt to poke/tweak to get devices working
Network Security Toolkit
- My AAO runs NST 24 most of the time - network/security probe running NTOP and Snort
- Nov 2017 - NST 26 SVN:9267 upgrade *** Aborted ***
- Overall: Live Boot worked well, but install went poorly. Features were not what I had hoped
- Live Boot: Things ran very well off of USB stick, fedora 26 seemed to get along fine on AAO
- Install was rough: No grub choice for standard Gnome Desktop - Fluxbox was default
- Security App Changes:
- No pre-installed OpenVAS (Vulnerability Scanner), I must have misread release notes
- Old NTOP was removed, I like/know that one. Will play w/ NTOPNG to be ready next time!
- Hoped to play with Snorby - not there
- Created 4g usb boot using iso and mint USB Disk utility
- Initial Boot from Live USB:
- Blueman takes a dump @ startup ("quit unexpectedly") - has happened since NST 22
- OS Runs fine, notes as I go
- WiFi - no prob
- Network - Win/Workgroup fine
- Audio output works
- trackpad, works fine, had to tweak to set tap-to-click
- Seems to have more general apps, media player for example
- Install Notes - I 'install' to a USB drive instead of using persistence ... can't recall why
- Apps
- old NTOP is gone! Oh NO! change! I liked that one! AAO constantly ran NTOP!
- ntopng - it works .... but...
- had to set admin password to match nstpassword? THEN login with admin/admin(!) and change it again via WebUI ... I need to retrace my steps here
- Need to figure out filters - need to ignore the probe itself?
- no show stopper, more testing needed
- snort/snorby - TBD, BASE is gone, but I'd like to run snorby
- Fumbling as usual
- <punted>
- October 2017 - Gentoo! Never-mind, didn't work well, aborted - notes below
- September 2017 - Updated Parrot Security Scanner to v3.8, works great
AAO has been working great in the following roles:
- 22-23 July 2017 - Took 2 days, but updated to Win 10 Creator (v1703). Works pretty well, but would not attempt on stock 1g AAO. notes/observations below. Simply wanted to make sure MS still supports AAO
- 02 February 2017 - Playing w/ Parrot 3.4.1, "IoT Security in mind" - looks good
- 16 Feb - Parrot is running great - may be Kali replacement. A few notes
- Jan 2017 - Updated AAO security probe NST 24 SVN 7977 64-bit see notes
- 28 December 2016 - Knoppix v7.7.1! Worked OK. Distro is Loaded with apps!
- 21 December 2016 - Updated my Kali Flash Drive to v2016.2 - Success!
- December 2016 - A little page reorganizing - running out of room.
- Tests and notes from 2013-2015 moved to the bottom of the page. Many of these may be outdated due to OS releases, updates ...
- 19 November 2016 - Security Onion 14.04.5.1 64-bit. Interesting IDS Distro
- October 2016 - Bit the bullet and added RAM to the good old AAO.
- 30 August 2016 - Puppy (Slacko) 6.3.2 32-bit - Nice, fast, works very well
- 27 August 2016 - Gave up on Mageia 5 KDE 32-Bit, never figured out Live
- 19 August 2016 - Some cleanup and new tests
- Removed Ubuntu from chart below - aborted attempt to run 13.04
- Brief attempt @ Elementary OS 3.2 AAO hung on splash "e" screen,
- 31 May 2016, Updated AAO to Win 10 - went well, some tweaks, SLOW!
2016-2017 Tests
Ratings: A=Perfect (out of box), F=Total Fail
|
|
Puppy (Slacko) |
|
Kali |
Knoppix |
Parrot |
(Fedora)
|
gentoo |
Fix Major Annoyances |
|
|
|
|
|
In
USE
|
In
USE
|
Abort
:-(
|
Fast user switching |
F! |
n/a |
see
notes
|
A |
no
test
|
|
|
B |
Personalization1
|
B |
B |
A |
A |
A |
A |
B |
A |
Autorun Portable Devices
|
C |
C |
A |
A |
C |
C |
A |
C |
Upgrade $$$!
|
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
General Simplicity3 |
C |
C |
B |
C |
C |
B |
B |
C |
Our World
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Home Network Participant |
A |
B |
see
notes
|
A |
A |
A |
A |
D |
Music Library Participant
|
A |
C |
n/a |
F |
D |
n/a |
D |
|
Home Applications |
A |
D |
n/a |
n/a |
B |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
Software |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Apps/Add-ons Availability |
A |
C |
D |
C |
A |
A |
A |
C |
Ongoing Evolution/Support |
A |
B |
B |
B |
B |
A |
C |
C |
Hardware
(532h-2588)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Touch pad
(2-finger scroll)
|
A |
A |
A |
B |
C |
A |
A |
B |
Webcam |
A |
A |
A |
n/a |
A |
A4 |
B4 |
|
Card Reader
|
|
F |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Audio Input (mic) |
B |
D |
|
F |
C |
A |
B |
|
Audio Output |
B |
C |
A |
F |
C |
A |
A |
|
External Monitor
|
|
F |
A |
A |
F |
A |
A |
F |
WiFi |
C |
A |
A |
A |
B |
A |
A |
A |
Ethernet |
B |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Power Management
|
B |
B |
A |
A |
B |
A |
A |
D |
Keyboard/Function Keys
|
A |
C |
B |
C |
C |
C |
A |
C |
USB Slots |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Misc |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Version Tested |
v1703 |
6.3.2
|
14.04.5.1
(64-bit)
|
2016.2
(32-bit) |
v7.71 |
3.8
(64-bit)
|
24 SVN 7977
(64-bit) |
4.5.2 |
1 Change Wallpaper, Screensaver, Visual Style, etc - Where Win 7 Starter totally fails
2 VERY Clumsy with wifi, mapped drives, network printers, and non-windows peers
3 Intuitiveness, e.g. Finding/installing drivers/software, locating files, Security & Maintenance reboots ......
4 Installed Cheese and/or Google voice/video to test
2016-2017 Test Notes
Win 10
- Works pretty well - STILL TWEAKING, but IS USABLE especially after adding memory*
- Pretty tight on memory, Still working on making more avail for apps
- Chrome is a PIG - pretty much un-usable! Probably due to memory
- Initial Performance tweaks:
- Turned off Animations - sysdm.cpl/performance/visual effects; Adjust for best performance
- Attempting to Shut up Cortana - Settings/Privacy/Speech, Inking & Typing: click "Stop getting to know me!" BUT She is still running ... more to come
- Windows 10 Creator (v1703) - July 2017
Elementary OS
- Had been playing with Elementarty OS on a desktop, decided to give it a boot on the AAO.
- Failed - never got past splash screen
Mageia 5
- Always liked Mandrake, came up great on AAO - but gave up on testing/tinkering
- Testing cut short, Aborted - never did figure out USB persistence - lost interest and patience
- Touch pad worked out of box with right/bottom scroll areas, but no real tweaks that I could see (e.g. 2finger scrolling is a fav)
- WiFi worked out of box - little different configuration
- Power Management seemed to work fine, even suspend/resume, but noted some odd auto brightness adjustments while running on battery
- Little slow/sluggish running off of USB stick
- Didn't test mic or camera
Puppy Slacko
- Nice! Fast!
- Different: Not really Multi-User, session can be saved/restored - so no 'Fast User Switching"
- Win Workgroups and Linux Network shares came right up
- Lots of stuff installed/buit-in - a tad cluttered on AAO display ... BUT many nice facilities, including a tool to remove built-in packages!
- Used pAVrecord to test webcam
- Did not get audio input working, but pretty sure I could if I tinkered with ALSA, inbuilt sound could probably use a tweak or two - sounded like crap
- Persistence is a gimme! You setup persistence and save config during first shutdown/restart - Nice!
Security Onion
- Originally tested to simplify Snort install/setup
- Based on ubuntu 14.04 64-bit
- 14.04 Release Notes: Little disappointed, no Live Boot option, no Snorby
- No Live Boot: Couldn't find/figure out LiveCD, ended up doing an install to a 32g USB flash drive. 3 partitions - 8g ext4 for /, 4g swap and 20g ext4 for me (home). so far so good
- Based on Ubuntu 14.04 ... works a lot better than 13.04 (abort!), but still quirky.
- Mouse Pointer disappears - probably this bug - its annoying, always happens after sleep/wake sequence
My lame work-around:
- Bring up app menu by moving imaginary mouse pointer to upper left
- Type some stuff in search box of programs menu while moving mouse
- Mouse pointer eventually reappears (Yeeeesh!)
- Misc Notes
- System appears to be nicely locked-down from firewall (iptables) perspective, did not fiddle to test home network. Even struggled with ssh to access system!
- Personalization, user switching, etc handled by outer Ubuntu 14.04, features seemed to be intact
- Not what I was looking for. I wanted a simple way to spin-up a portable IDS and plug into our home network to watch over things (IoT world in particular). Looking forward to *not* installing/configuring snort/snorby, but seeing how they work. Snorby was no longer avail on SO 14.04
Kali
- Updated to Kali 2016.2 32-bit on 32g Flash Drive. I needed more space for logs, capture files and such
- No audio devices, a few fcn keys work. Overall appears to be solid
- Config steps and links so I don't have to find them next time!
- Live, Persistent Kali USB drive @ kali.org/prst
- Tweaking in process
- AAO Trackpad - turn on Tap to Click, but still a bit touchy/odd
- service ssh start (as needed)
- snort/snorby - I punted, not using snort/snorby under kali - it was a pain to install/configure
- Kali is now my road warrior boot - for external scans and such away from home
- NST used as probe, IDS, monitor, etc when AAO is on home network
KNOPPIX
- KNOPPIX 7.7 - install to flash disk to get reusable environment, I didn't bother
- It talks (Audio) when it boots!
- LOTS of applications, very nice UI and pretty snappy on AAO
- Almost too much included with the distro - you have to sift through applications and menus
- Audio did not work out of the box - record or playback. Fiddled a little with kmixer, probably OK
- Touchpad worked, but never found the tweaks I use for 2 finger scrolling and tapping
- Some function keys appeared to work - Mute, Brightness and monitor on/off
- Networking worked out of the box. One slight hiccup with WiFi required reboot
Network Security Toolkit
- My AAO runs NST most of the time now - quite useful as a network/security probe
more @ http://www.networksecuritytoolkit.org
- Jan 2017 - NST 24:SVN 7977 - works VERY Well
- Successfully updated to 24:SVN 7977 64-Bit - lots of nice tools
- "Installed" to a 32g memory stick this time - instead of live boot w/ persistence
- Notes to self (stuff I struggle with each time I upgrade this one)
- Runs great on AAO - lots of security tools accessible via web browser
- Nov 2017 - NST 26 SVN:9267 upgrade *** In Process ***
- Mostly interested in OpenVAS (Vulnerability Scanner) and snort UI (snorby), release notes @ http://www.networksecuritytoolkit.org
- Created 4g usb boot using iso and mint USB Disk utility
- Initial Boot from Live USB:
- Blueman takes a dump @ startup ("quit unexpectedly") - has happened since NST 22
- OS Runs fine, notes as I go, will fill-in test table later
- WiFi - no prob
- Network - Win/Workgroup fine
- Audio output works
- trackpad, works fine, had to tweak to set tap-to-click
- old NTOP is gone! Oh NO! change! I liked that one! AAO constantly ran NTOP!
- ntopng - it works .... but...
- had to set admin password to match nstpassword? THEN login with admin/admin(!) and change it again via WebUI ... I need to retrace my steps here
- Need to figure out filters - need to ignore the probe itself?
- no show stopper, more testing needed
- snort/snorby - TBD, BASE is gone
Parrot
- Security Oriented OS, runs great on AAO!
- Followed Parrot Live Install Procedure to create 3.4.1 Live USB. Booted fine on AAO
- Lots of Security Tools! Well organized.
- Mate bottom panel gets in the way of dialogs periodically - set to autohide on AAO
- Looks REALLY good - Playing with persistence so I can put some more miles on it
- Ended up moving to 16g USB Stick w/ persistence. Some tools require space to install/use
- Quite possibly a replacement for my Kali portable security toolkit
- OpenVAS vulnerability scanner is pre-installed, typically a BEAR to get up and running.
Steps (and notes to self):
- Sept 2017 update:
- Now using Parrot on AAO instead of Kali for portable security scans and such
- Recreated my 16g Live Boot USB using v3.8 64-bit Full Edition - MUCH faster than upgrading
Steps (in case I need to do this again)
Gentoo
- Aborted tests - lots of odd shit to deal with: GUI apps failing, authority (even as root)
- Installed livedvd-x86-amd64-32ul-20160704.iso
- Had to boot with no Framebuffer (no fb) to get GUI up
- if using USB boot - here's Persistence setup
- Keyboard: Most function keys appeared to work, no menu w/ windows button
- Power MGT: Didn't appear to deal with Battery, no monitoring
- External Monitor did not appear to work
- 19 November 2015, Network Security Toolkit 22 SVN:7334 - due to Kali 1.x EOL - see notes below. Works fine!
- 20 October 2015, Kali 2.0 32-bit, downloaded and began testing, but seemed sluggish and unstable - more to come
- 17 December 2014, Kali 1.0.9a 32-bit - works great! Still working on Kali tools, but outer OS seems to work fine!!
- 13 April 2014, Kali (Backtrack rebirth) 1.0.6 32-bit - aborted testing
- 10 April 2014, PCLinuxOS MATE32 2014.04, Nice looking splash screen - that's all I saw
- 01 April 2014, Xubuntu Desktop 13.10 32-bit .... half-baked assessment (mem stick overwritten)
- 01 October 2013, SideTracked by BackTrack 5 RC 3, 32-bit, KDE. Works GREAT! May be destiny for my AAO
- 28 July 2013, Xubuntu Desktop 13.04 32-Bit ... still working on this one
- 24 June 2013, Fedora 18 32-Bit. Quirky. Had to fumble with settings to get working (good old Linux experience)
- 21 June 2013, kubuntu 13.04 32-Bit. Struggled with network participation and SD card reader, nice UI (Plasma)
- 19 June 2013, Ubuntu Desktop 13.04 32-Bit. ABORTED, ran like crap
- 6 June 2013, Linux Mint 15 32-Bit (Olivia) with Mate Desktop COMPLETED, NICE!
2013-2015 Tests
Ratings: A=Perfect (out of box), F=Total Fail
|
Win 7
Starter
|
Linux
Mint
(Mate) |
kubuntu
Linux |
Fedora
(hints)
|
Xubuntu
Linux |
BackTrack
Linux |
|
NST
(Fedora) |
Fix Major Annoyances |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Fast user switching |
F
|
A
|
A |
C |
A
|
A |
A |
A |
Personalization1
|
D
|
B
|
B
|
C |
B
|
A |
A |
B |
Autorun Portable Devices
|
F |
A
|
A |
C |
|
A |
A |
A |
Upgrade $$$!
|
$80! |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
$0 |
General Simplicity3 |
D |
B
|
B |
D |
C |
B |
B |
B |
Our World
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Home Network Participant |
D2 |
A
|
D
|
F |
D |
B |
A |
A |
Music Library Participant
|
A |
C
|
C |
D |
|
n/a |
n/a |
D |
Home Applications4 |
A |
B
|
B |
B |
B |
n/a |
n/a |
n/a |
Software |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Apps/Add-ons Availability |
C |
A |
A |
A |
A |
C |
D |
A |
Ongoing Evolution/Support |
C |
A
|
A |
A |
A |
Whoops! |
C |
C |
Hardware
(532h-2588)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Touch pad
(2-finger scroll)
|
B |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
Webcam |
B |
B4 |
B4 |
A |
B4 |
n/a |
A |
B4 |
Card Reader
|
C |
A |
F |
F |
F |
A |
A |
A |
Audio Input (mic) |
B |
C |
B |
B |
B |
n/a |
F |
B |
Audio Output |
C |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
A |
External Monitor
|
A |
A |
A |
D |
|
B |
A |
A |
WiFi |
C |
A |
A |
C2 |
A |
B |
A |
A |
Ethernet |
B |
A |
A |
A |
|
A |
A |
A |
Power Management
|
B |
B |
B |
B |
|
B |
C |
B |
Keyboard/Function Keys
|
A |
C |
C |
C |
|
C |
A |
A |
USB Slots |
A |
A |
A |
A |
|
A |
A |
A |
Misc |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Version Tested |
|
15 |
13.04 |
18 |
13.10 |
BT 5 RC3, KDE
|
1.09a |
22 SVN
:7334 |
1 Change Wallpaper, Screensaver, Visual Style, etc - Where Win 7 Starter totally fails
2 VERY Clumsy with wifi, mapped drives, network printers, and non-windows peers
3 Intuitiveness, e.g. Finding/installing drivers/software, locating files, Security & Maintenance reboots ......
4 Installed Cheese and/or Google voice/video to test
2013-2015 Test Notes:
- All tested via Live USB boot with 2g of persistence when possible
- Mint - Worked very well. Fast, easy to work with. AAO hardware worked right out of the box with the exception of the mic, which required fiddling to get working - used this post http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=1379587. Connected nicely to mac world, windoze network and network printer (Dell M5200). Mate is snappy and easy to use.
- Ubuntu was rough - did not run well at all. Slow, periodically unresponsive, not worth continued effort. Aborted.
- kubunu - a little disappointing, KDE Plasma Desktop is cool. A lot of good old Linux monkeying around to achieve network participation. Never did get SD card reader working. Live USB boot seemed slower and more cumbersome than Mint. Periods of slugishness/unresponsiveness.
- Fedora - Some probs switching between wifi networks - would not release network connection dialog box, had to reboot. Lots of fiddling to participate in home (windows & mac) network. External monitor was flaky, appeared to be related to differences in resolution/aspect.
- BackTrack - Specialty distro (security tools) but a VERY pleasant surprise, it runs great on AAO 532h. Tested KDE (plasma) window manager, but didn't mess around testing hardware or features that wouldn't be used for security scans, audits and such ("n/a" in table above). Odd/sporadic issues adding software via kPackage.
- Xubuntu - Attempt #2, little rough, tinkering required. Takes dumps on startup (ubuntu internal error and keyboard input method), connecting to smb network did not work out of the box. Some AAO hardware seems to be working., Doesn't seem as fast as Mint ... Maybe more to come
- Kali - Attempt #2. Live/USB is pretty painless/easy - http://docs.kali.org/installation/kali-linux-live-usb-install. Some fiddling to get persistence http://docs.kali.org/installation/kali-linux-live-usb-persistence. Internal mic didn't seem to work (very quick test), internal/external audio seemed fine via smoking monkey youtube test. USB, cardreader, external monitor and trackpad worked with no putzing. Kali tools don't seem to be as fully baked as BT - but could just be learning curve.
- Kali 2.0 - Somewhat of a forced update due to 1.0 EOL and repository purge. Had a heck of a time going back to 1.1 with persistence for some reason. I'd recommend sticking with Kali 1.x on the Aspire for the time being and using archive mirror for time being ("deb http://old.kali.org/kali moto main non-free contrib" in /etc/apt/sources.list)
- NST 22 - Looks REALLY good! Still some testing to do, but the toolkit (and fedora) seems to function well on AAO!
- 11/11 - Didn't make it through the night - looks to be hung, power management?
- 11/19 - More testing with new USB stick (w/ 1g of persistence). Will switch to NST until Kali 2.0 has a few more miles on it.
- Card reader works fine, I initially used a bad adapter
- Little burp at Startup - bluman takes a dump when you initially boot (probably due to no bluetooth)
- Power Management seems fine, no hangs, features seem to work
- Built-in Audio seems fine - input levels seem to change when testing mic, output tested fine
- Did some putzing with Exile media player - did not work out of the box
- Fedora Live USB Creator is a little flaky. After adding persistence it fails with "vesamenu.c32: not COM32R image" during boot. Workaround for now: Tab Key, then enter 'gdm' to bring up mate
---------------
* T. Pedersen Ventures is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
|